The Lawyer For A Carter County Man Accused Of Rape And Murder Says The Death Penalty Is Unconstitutional In The Case Against Chad Benfield. Prosecutors Believe He Should Die If Convicted And Raping A Killing 89 Year Old Mary Nolen At Her Home In Stoney Creek In 2017. Benfield Was A Neighbor. His Trial Is Set In January But His Attorney’s Will Argue The Death Penalty On September 12th.