A Sullivan County Man Previously Charged With Second-Degree Murder Has Been Convicted Of A Lesser Charge James Fagans Was Convicted Last Week On Voluntary Manslaughter, Aggravated Robbery, And Aggravated Assault The Second-Degree Murder Charge Was Dismissed Fagans’ Charges Stem From An Investigation Into The 2018 Death Of Herman Rumbley, Who Was Found Dead In His Bluff City Home A Sentencing Hearing For Fagans Is Scheduled For March 4.